Skip navigation
Contact No's - ROI 048 3755 1260  NI   028 3755 1260

Carbon storage plan fraught with difficulties

PROFESSOR Stuart Haszeldine's enthusiasm for storing carbon dioxide under the North Sea (“North Sea assets can offer means to achieve climate change targets”, Agenda, The Herald, May 16) leads him to overlook at least two problems which must be overcome before this would be possible.

The first and most difficult task in carbon capture and storage is capture. No economic large-scale process yet exists to do this. The prospects for any process for retrofitting to coal fired power stations are particularly unpromising.

Secondly there is the problem of collection and transportation.

Every tonne of methane burned produces 2.75 tonnes of carbon dioxide and their densities differ by this same factor. This would make transport by pipeline more expensive.

Neither liquefied natural gas (LNG) nor liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) tankers would be suitable for its shipping. There is certainly no existing infrastructure which could readily collect CO2 throughout Europe and take it to Scotland.

The production of hydrogen from methane is by no means “low cost” when account is taken of all losses.

Because of its very different physical properties it is by no means clear that the existing gas network would be suitable for large-scale distribution of hydrogen. As a domestic fuel its very wide explosive limits and easy ignition would raise safety concerns.

Prof Jack Ponton,

Scientific Alliance Scotland,

7-9 North St David Street, Edinburgh.

Current Issues


Future costs of UK energy supply

The Scientific Alliance recently published part 1 of an examination of National Grid's Future Energy Scenarios, dealing with security of supply. We are now pleased to publish part 2 - cost of supply. The authors - Dr Capell Aris and Colin Gibson - conclude that building more gas and nuclear stations would be considerably less expensive than any of the NG scenarios, as well as offering better energy security.

What's New

14 October 2016: Read the new report by Dr Capell Aris, published jointly with the Adam Smith Institute - Solar power in Britain: the Impossible Dream